Online Now 2094

BOL Round Table

The No. 1 'Bama fan community on the Internet

On this Board 3127
Record: 6133 (1/15/2013)

Online now 3636
Record: 9097 (3/2/2012)

Boards ▾

BOL Round Table

The No. 1 'Bama fan community on the Internet

The Water Cooler

BOL message board for off-topic posts

Ticket Exchange

Buy, sell or swap tickets

Reply

McCarron and Yeldon fumbled handoff

  • Watching the play set up was beautiful. The OL blocked the play perfectly, there was a huge running lane between Fluker and Steen. If they didn't fumble that was a walk in TD. I was really impressed with the way the blocks were made.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Bamaskins

  • This post is for members of BamaOnLine only. Join now! Subscribe Now
    signature image signature image signature image

    bamabiscuit ●

  • That's what made me so mad when it happened. Would have put us up 21-10 and yes play was blocked to perfection. Luckily we still got the win. O-Line was amazing last night.

    dkb2238

  • Yeldon would have hit his noggin on the goal post.....if he had gotten the rock. Until the screen td that was the biggest play of the game. 14 point swing because of that play. Made up for it though. RMFT

    jhuck55

  • I agree completely. I said exactly the same thing when it happened. Yeldon could have walked into the endzone. Still, the fumble set up one of the most dramatic finishes in Bama football history....so it was, in that sense, an important part of the story.

    Bamawester ●

  • Was Yeldon credited with the fumble? If so is that his first fumble of his career? Even tho I don't think it should be credited to him, since was a bad handoff. So hate it if it is his first and its not even his fault.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Bamaskins

  • Bamaskins said...

    Was Yeldon credited with the fumble? If so is that his first fumble of his career? Even tho I don't think it should be credited to him, since was a bad handoff. So hate it if it is his first and its not even his fault.

    I know the football logic says that it is the QBs responsibility to plant the handoff in the RBs gut. And it looked like AJ was a little hurried trying to get back and execute the 2nd fake to the sweep. So definitely AJ deserves some of the blame
    But, IMO I think TJ fouled up too. if you look at the replay from the rear view, it looked like TJ saw the huge hole that our OL had already created, and he began to veer to the right before getting the ball. AJ, never had a chance to complete the handoff b/c TJ was leaving their point of contact.

    Dual culpability IMO. Both guys were heading in opposite directions. Both got a little overanxious. I think they knew that play was money, and got impatient.

    Bama_Lefty

  • Bama_Lefty said...

    I know the football logic says that it is the QBs responsibility to plant the handoff in the RBs gut. And it looked like AJ was a little hurried trying to get back and execute the 2nd fake to the sweep. So definitely AJ deserves some of the blame But, IMO I think TJ fouled up too. if you look at the replay from the rear view, it looked like TJ saw the huge hole that our OL had already created, and he began to veer to the right before getting the ball. AJ, never had a chance to complete the handoff b/c TJ was leaving their point of contact.

    Dual culpability IMO. Both guys were heading in opposite directions. Both got a little overanxious. I think they knew that play was money, and got impatient.

    agreed We will probably see that play again, hopefully with a better hand off.biggrin

    This post was edited by 442Bama on 11/4/2012 at 11:42 AM

    signature image signature image signature image

    1984 300ZX Anniversary Model, 1970 Olds 442 W-30 & Pepper Bird

    442Bama

  • Yes. He would easily housed it. So frustrating.

    manbearpig7

  • Bama_Lefty said...

    I know the football logic says that it is the QBs responsibility to plant the handoff in the RBs gut. And it looked like AJ was a little hurried trying to get back and execute the 2nd fake to the sweep. So definitely AJ deserves some of the blame
    But, IMO I think TJ fouled up too. if you look at the replay from the rear view, it looked like TJ saw the huge hole that our OL had already created, and he began to veer to the right before getting the ball. AJ, never had a chance to complete the handoff b/c TJ was leaving their point of contact.

    Dual culpability IMO. Both guys were heading in opposite directions. Both got a little overanxious. I think they knew that play was money, and got impatient.

    I could see that happening. Yeldon leaning away trying to hit the hole quicker.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Bamaskins

  • Bama_Lefty said...

    I know the football logic says that it is the QBs responsibility to plant the handoff in the RBs gut. And it looked like AJ was a little hurried trying to get back and execute the 2nd fake to the sweep. So definitely AJ deserves some of the blame
    But, IMO I think TJ fouled up too. if you look at the replay from the rear view, it looked like TJ saw the huge hole that our OL had already created, and he began to veer to the right before getting the ball. AJ, never had a chance to complete the handoff b/c TJ was leaving their point of contact.

    Dual culpability IMO. Both guys were heading in opposite directions. Both got a little overanxious. I think they knew that play was money, and got impatient.

    Even if yeldon leans it's the qb's responsiblity to put it squarely in the basket.

    ReasonableDoubt ●

  • ReasonableDoubt said...

    Even if yeldon leans it's the qb's responsiblity to put it squarely in the basket.

    I understand that, and know that is the old football saying, but if the RB literally veers so far away that the QB cannot reach the "basket" then he (the QB) has no way to put it there. If you notice, AJ's arm appeared to be fully extended. He was trying to get it there. But both of them had begun to veer away from their meeting point.

    Bama_Lefty

  • Why must we blame someone? They're both great players who almost never make a mistake.

    RSemmes

  • FWIW, I watched the game with a former Bama qb and he blamed AJ.

    Bama59

  • AJ looked very lax on that handoff and not putting right in the gut

    signature image signature image signature image

    Bama Boz

  • it looked as if TJ started left too soon watching the hole

    signature image

    --------------

    Joshb42

  • This post is for members of BamaOnLine only. Join now! Subscribe Now
    signature image signature image
    signature image

    Ronald Reagan: Man is not free unless government is limited.

    rdekonen

  • This post is for members of BamaOnLine only. Join now! Subscribe Now

    NickRTR86

  • Joshb42 said...

    it looked as if TJ started left too soon watching the hole

    It is the QB's responsibility to get the hand-off in the RB's breadbasket period. The QB is looking at the RB while the RB is looking at the line. As long as Yeldon didn't go to the wrong side of the line, which he didn't then it is AJ's fumble.

    signature image signature image signature image

    blount4bama

Alabama
247Sports
Features
Resources
Connect

247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports